Start with the page, not the domain
Domain metrics get all the attention, but your link lives on a page. First question: is that page indexed? Paste the URL into Google with site: — no result means no crawl, and a link on an uncrawled page is a donation.
Second: does the page have organic keywords? Tools like Ahrefs or Semrush show you in seconds. Pages that rank for something pass more value than pages that exist for nobody.
The traffic check
A site with zero estimated traffic is usually a site Google stopped trusting. We treat anything under ~500 monthly visits as a caution for editorial placements, and the bar rises with the authority being claimed.
Traffic also validates the publisher. Sites with real visitors protect their reputations; link farms with none have nothing to lose.
Relevance beats metrics
Look at the last ten articles on the site. Are any near your topic? A DA 35 niche site will frequently outperform a DA 60 generalist for long-tail movement, because the topical signal is cleaner.
This is why we match placements to niches instead of selling raw domain scores. The 'perfect metric, wrong topic' purchase is the most common disappointment we hear about.
Red flags that disqualify fast
Outbound link counts exploding month over month. Casino and pharma links mixed into a parenting blog. Bylines that repeat across hundreds of unrelated posts. A homepage that is essentially a directory of sponsored posts.
Any one of these is survivable. Three together means a network, and networks get devalued in groups — taking your link down with them.
The 5-minute checklist
Indexed page ✓ — organic keywords present ✓ — traffic above the floor ✓ — topical fit within two clicks ✓ — outbound growth sane ✓. Five checks, five minutes, and you'll dodge most of the inventory that wastes budgets.
If you're buying from a marketplace, ask the seller to answer these about their inventory. Honest sellers answer quickly, because they already know.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ahrefs, Semrush or Moz all work. Pick one and learn it — the screening logic matters more than the tool brand.
Spot-check 10–20% of large orders plus anything that feels off. Full audits of 500-link batches rarely pay for the time.